James Powell, a college senior, falls for Bess Gunther, a sophomore. However, the attractive Bess is deeply in love with F. Scott Fitzgerald, or "Scotty", as she likes to call him. The obsession leads Bess down a road James prefers not to follow. Years later, he wonders whether she's the one that got away.

Alexa Davalos
Bess Gunther

Sasha Andreev
Librarian

Charlie Hofheimer
James Powell
Charles Lyons
Released